An apology re an apology re Momentum!

So, last week, I deleted my original article on Momentum last week, after two friends told me it read like an attack. I replaced it with an apology. However, since then, I’ve now received three responses from friends telling me that my original article did not read as an attack and was instead an important and necessary critique. Two of these friends told me that they forwarded it to others who said that it also chimed with their own experiences of Momentum and the Labour Party more generally.

I agree that any individual and organisation should be open to critique and that was the spirit in which I wrote the original piece. I was not silenced by anyone. I was just wary about attacking anyone.

I planned to restore the original article to this site, but I’ve deleted it now.
So suffice to say that in the article I critiqued the organisational practices of Momentum which, I believed, would not enable the group to recruit enthusiastic new members, cultivate internal democracy, nor achieve the political goals it set itself. In short, from my personal experiences, I couldn’t see Momentum sustaining momentum and argued for a more inclusive, participatory, decentralised approach that focused on building relationships as a priority. I also argued that if Labour Party people saw their fight as against the Blairites then this also meant that they should focus not on the Blairites, but on reaching out in democratic alliance with grassroots groups, movements, and campaigns. Momentum rises from below, was the main message.

In conclusion, thanks to those who both critiqued the article as attack and to those who assured me that it was well judged and important. I’m very glad to receive your feedback. I hope this brief journey shows all my readers that I’m very open to criticism, I’m prone to errors of judgment, and that I seek to attack no one.



4 thoughts on “An apology re an apology re Momentum!”

  1. You were right about Momentum. As far as I’m concerned it’s a serious issue. Only 18% of the electorate voted Labour, suggesting 82% of the electorate didn’t think they were worth voting for. It was Corbyn talking about the issues that matter to people that prompted so many to pay their three quid and vote for him and made a proportion of those join or re-join the Labour Party. The country is screaming for the new kind of politics that Corbyn was offering.

    The Momentum meeting I went to in Greater Manchester was extremely disappointing – run by Labour Party insiders get people to go to branch meetings and provide the numbers for their faction to take over. Talk about throwing a bucket of cold water – heart breaking really!

    I’ve tried repeatedly since then to reach whoever is organising Momentum for Greater Manchester, without luck. Your critique was called for Joel.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s